Mad Social Scientist ([info]mawaridi) wrote,
@ 2006-04-25 13:01:00
Previous Entry  Add to memories!  Tell a Friend  Next Entry
Current mood: pissed off

Have one for Australia.
Today I discovered a full page ad in the Herald Sun (page 14 of 25/4/06) that dumbfounded me in its audacity. I couldn't decide whether to be outraged or amused. It was written and entirely funded by Gary Johnston, a private citizen who claims to be affiliated with no political party or special interest group, and it has a website address one can visit for more information. Anyway, here is the advertisement.

The website is the bizarrely named http://www.play2upnow.com.au There are two versions of the ad on the website. The one I haven't linked to directly has the addition of a disturbing tagline: "Your child could be dedicated to the ANZACS who never came back" and says that we can "give some meaning to all that senseless death" by having 2.1 children instead of 1.7.

First of all, I resent and completely reject the idea that my duty to my country is to act as a baby factory to keep the population going. Please note that the ad, written by a man, specifies birth rate "per female," not per person, couple, family or household. But that's an issue that we've seen surrounding shrinking birth rate moral panics for some time. The message behind this ad seems to me to be far more insidious and offensive than simply suggesting it is a woman's duty to give birth.

Centring the campaign around ANZAC day and the idea that we need to replace Australian men who died at war, and the children they never had a chance to have, is not only using sneaky means to guilt people into having more children, it's also attributing creepy motives to increasing the Australian birth rate. Is Mr. Johnston suggesting that we should be boosting the population because Australia needs more cannon fodder? If all I have to look forward to for my children is sending them away to die in wars I don't agree with, then this ad makes me feel even more secure in my decision not to have children. I'm not just protecting myself from a life of childcare I expect I would neither enjoy nor be good at. I am choosing to protect my unborn offspring from being used as human shields - or worse, offensive weapons - by their government.

The disclaimer at the bottom of the ad says that "the writer acknowledges that immigration is an essential part of this country's population but that immigration should augment our population, not dominate it." I wonder how he feels about international adoption? Would babies from other (often overpopulated and disadvantaged) countries be Australian enough for him?



(8 comments) - (Post a new comment)


[info]fin
2006-04-25 03:56 am UTC (link)
A couple of interesting things from the website...

"If immigration dominated over domestic population growth in 50 years – living memory – the national character of the country would change in ways we just cannot imagine."

Umm... okay. So if we adopt children from other countries at a very young age, and bring them up in our families in our own "Australian" domestic environment, how *exactly* does it change our "national character", other than the way we look?

Interestingly enough, he is pro-choice too, but in a kinda twisted way...

"If you are very young, have a drug problem or do not have a stable relationship with the father, do not allow others to influence you to have a baby because of anything you or others read on this website. You should seek the advice of your doctor and other professionals who are in the best position to assess your individual needs. Please, we do not want an unloved baby to come into this world for any sentimental reasons that may be erroneously attributed to what we hope to achieve."

Basically, if you're not going to bring good old fashioned family values to a child, then don't breed.

(Reply to this)

:o
[info]shehasathree
2006-04-25 06:31 am UTC (link)
wow. i am so not awake enough to get my head around this right now.

(Reply to this)


[info]sajee
2006-04-25 11:21 am UTC (link)
*cries*

WHY??

(Reply to this)


[info]aphephobia
2006-04-25 01:18 pm UTC (link)
Yet these are the same arseholes who say single mothers shouldn't get welfare and that a child needs to grow up in a nuclear, heterosexual family.

If I have to "have kids for" anything, I hope mine are for bringing on the revolution.


The ANZAC stuff I've seen today has upset me, as it always does, but some of it has outright scared/i> me. There was a song on 9am which is usually a fairly left-of-centre show, about how pretty much supporting the war is a good thing.

While I feel for the families of the soldiers who've died, I think if anything, it's a tribute to how senseless and destructive war is. Not an argument to go blowing up Iraq because of George Bush's power trip. If that makes me un-Australian, so be it.

Centring the campaign around ANZAC day and the idea that we need to replace Australian men who died at war, and the children they never had a chance to have, is not only using sneaky means to guilt people into having more children, it's also attributing creepy motives to increasing the Australian birth rate

It reminds me when people compare the Holocaust to abortion rates, which, I'm sorry- is inaccurate, mean, and wrong.


Is Mr. Johnston suggesting that we should be boosting the population because Australia needs more cannon fodder? If all I have to look forward to for my children is sending them away to die in wars I don't agree with, then this ad makes me feel even more secure in my decision not to have children.

That really upsets me. I've got two sons. My oldest is one of the kindest, most sensitive people I know. The thought of him just being bred so some crappy right-wing government can send him off to somewhere to go killing people, without a thought about his welfare (oh, sure, he'd get commemorated if he was killed, but that is NOT the point) makes me want to cry. I guess I'll just have to keep taking him to anti-war protests and telling him about the realities of the government. What do they think this is-- Star Wars? My kids aren't part of a clone army.

Man... I feel sick thinking about this. I fucking hate this stupid country.

(Reply to this)


[info]shehasathree
2006-04-25 02:01 pm UTC (link)
look, Americans can be Stupid too!

(Reply to this)


[info]primroseburrows
2006-04-26 12:37 am UTC (link)
That's just weird.

(Reply to this)


[info]oh_contraire
2006-04-26 02:38 am UTC (link)
Ah, the militarisation of history and the patriotic breeding program that worked so well for so many totalitarian states.

But at least the forums at his site are full of people making fun of him... which, I have to say, is better than I expected.

(Reply to this)


[info]pink_soprano
2006-04-26 05:24 am UTC (link)
And that damn ad appears to have been in every major newspaper in the country...and it's fucking huge...couldn't he have done something useful with all that money?!?!?

(Reply to this)


(8 comments) - (Post a new comment)

Create an Account
Forgot your login or password?
Login w/ OpenID
English • Español • Deutsch • Русский…